Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?
[x]

deviantART

 
About Me Member Mad Scientist midgetness17/Female/Australia Recent Activity Deviant for 5 Years
Needs Premium Membership
Statistics 31 Deviations
234 Comments
1,099 Pageviews

the orangeness is..

Newest

HP and Grindelwald

Fri Jun 9, 2006, 11:06 PM
Just my little HP theory...

Everyone seems to have noticed the significance of Dumbledore’s defeat of the dark lord Grindelwald in 1945. But who exactly is he?

We have to assume the time frame of the whole series.
On pg 102 of the UK edition of Chamber - Sir Nick's deathday was in1492, and we know it is his 500th death day – hence, it must be 1992 in Chamber.
We also know, on pg 180 of Chamber, that Voldemort was in his 5th year when the chamber was opened, which we know was 50 years before. Thus, it must be 1942 when Voldy was in his fifth year. Which means his last year at Hogwarts was 1944 – one year before Grindelwald was defeated.
Harry was born in 1980 (using the time frame established above) and when he was 1 year old and dropped off on the Dursley’s door step – Dumbledore says “11years” twice. "they've had precious little to celebrate for 11 years" (pg 13, Philosopher's) and "for 11 years I've been trying to persuade people to call him by his proper name: Voldemort." (pg 14, Philosopher’s).
So Voldy has been feared since 1970.

Questions:
1. We know that Dumbledore would only call him ‘Tom Riddle’ (his memory in Prince) and this was a year after he left school. So why would he say that he’s been trying for 11 years to get people to call him “Voldemort” when he wouldn’t in 1945? What has changed between 1945 and 1970?
2. Also, what was Voldemort doing between 1945 and 1970?
3. Why haven’t we heard anything about Grindelwald, except that he’s was a dark lord and that he was defeated in 1945? (In her interview with MuggleNet and The Leaky Cauldron, JKR said Grindelwald is dead.)

My speculation:
Grindelwald and Voldemort are the same person.

This would explain why Voldy fears Dumbledore and no one else.
Just because JKR says he’s dead, doesn’t mean he wasn’t a subpersonality of Voldy.
It would also explain why you can take “RIDDLE” out of “GRINDELWALD”. (Not that the other letters GNWAL have any significance, but then again, we don’t know if he has a first name or if there’s another bit to it like in I AM LORD VOLDEMORT.)

If JKR can make a riddle out of Riddle once, she can do it again.


- Shaney.

deviantID

Devious Info

  • Current Residence: Down Under
  • Interests: *shrug* i talk and debate. meh
  • Favourite movie: LOTR!!
  • Favourite band or musician: Goo Goo Dolls

deviantART Community Board

[x]

Comments


:iconfules-rool:
i'm bored, where did you go
i'm hungry... hows life

--
"he boggled-he'd never seen anyone sit on their own lap before"

"what is edward the 2nd divided by henry the 5th?"
:iconmidgetness:
im sick
stupid tonsilitis :(
how r u?
i was reading some of ur posts from the forum, lol
where did u find the time to post over 300?!
im a lab rat which is just sad. *sigh*
god i miss nysf
life without it is crappy
hope to see everyone soon!

--
**please tell me thats a wand...**
:iconfules-rool:
the funny thing is that from that over 300, atleast 220 were over 3 nights
which was pretty good considering the substance in each one
that was a weird week, one of my times with bad sleeping habits,
i think i went out all night saturday, worked early sunday, then started that spree on sunday night till 3am,
then had maths at quarter to 8 in th emorning, then stayed up till late again, then stayed in till late the next day and went till late again that night
it was a good week, well not really
i think as a result i lost my girlfriend
oh well

--
"he boggled-he'd never seen anyone sit on their own lap before"

"what is edward the 2nd divided by henry the 5th?"
:icontoro-chan:
Thankyou for the watch! ^^
:iconsaffron-anchec:
Trick or Treat, Trick or Treat, Give me something good to eat!
:iconmidgetness:
*hands over cookie*

--
**please tell me thats a wand...**
:iconsaffron-anchec:
Woot! *puts in bag*

Thanks
:iconmidgetness:
lol. sall good

--
**please tell me thats a wand...**
:iconkourinthellama:
Thank you for the sweet comment! :hug:

--
Did my post get you all worked up and you want to reply with RAGE? Read this first: [link]
:iconmidgetness:
no problemos!
:D

--
**please tell me thats a wand...**

existence is futile
mwah-ha-ha (evil laugh)

Site Map